Explaining the Covered Call
There are 3 possible scenarios: stock advances, stays flat or declines.
I paid $3.75 and then rented out these shares for $0.40. The renter has until May to buy my shares at $4.
First of all, that's 11% for a 7 week period - an enormous rate for such a short time.
This is due to the implicit volatility and the market's expectation that >$4 is very, very likely. In fact, it hit $4.20 last week.
Let's assume that it is option expiration day:
Scenario #1: ETFC >$4
The call will be exercised and I will get paid $4. That is $0.25 gain on the stock and $0.40 on the call. Total gain = $0.65 or 18%
Scenario #2: ETFC $3.40~$4
The call is unexercised. I still have the stock and my cost basis is $3.35 ($3.75-$0.40). I am ahead and can write another call or sell or hold.
I am protected at least 11% downside by the $0.40 I received for the call.
Scenario #3: ETFC <$3.35 The call is unexercised. I still have the stock and my cost basis is $3.35. I am at a loss, but I can write another call and further reduce my cost basis. So in 2 of 3 scenarios I am ahead. In the 3rd scenario, I am down. The stock hasn't closed below $3 in 10 weeks, which is saying a lot. But it did see $2.25 in early January. The trick is in choosing a stock that I feel is trending up, not down. 1. Business is up since January and they have an additional $1B in assets 2. They dumped their mortgage exposure last quarter 3. The recent Fed moves will lower investment companies costs while raising their profits. 4. ETFC is down 90% from June when they were $25 5. They are still profitable (ignoring the write-offs last quarter) So what might occur between now and May expiration? Lets say it is April 30th. Scenario #1: ETFC >$4
The call will most likely be exercised and I will get paid $4. That is $0.25 gain on the stock and $0.40 on the call. Total gain = $0.65 or 18%.
I could buy bcak the call, but I'll be paying more than $0.40. I would do this only if I thought that ETFC was about to zoom higher. Possibly a merger with TD Ameritrade. In that case, I would be trading the likelihood of an 18% gain in 7 weeks for some hoped-for higher return
Scenario #2: ETFC $3.40~$4
Anything is possible. I could buy the call back (close it out) and probably pay much less than I earned because options erode in value over time.
For example, if ETFC is $3.75, I would estimate that the May $4 call would be ~$0.25. So I could close out the call and sell the stock and net $0.15 or 4% in 1 month.
Scenario #3: ETFC <$3.35 Anything is possible, but the stock is clearly breaking down and re-visiting short term lows. After all, that is at least 11% below my purchase price and 25% below it's recent high. In any case, the $4 May call is probably super cheap: ~$.10. If i think the stock could crash further, I could sell the stock, I could close the call option and sell the stock, or I could close just the option and assume that this was a short term drop and that the stock will rise again. The key assumption here is that the stock isn't going down more than 15%~20% for any length of time. That is a VERY dangerous assumption and very risky. I am mitigating that risk (I hope) by carefully choosing a stock that seems to have bottomed. One last thing, I am deliberately writing short-term calls: 1 or 2 months at most. This gives me a good return while also retaining some flexibility. I actually hope for 1 of the following 2 scenarios: 1. ETFC >$4 in May. Lock in 18% in 7 weeks.
2. ETFC $3.35~$4. I would write another set of contracts, hopefully also for 11%.
My hope is that eventually the options are exercised and someone takes my stock. But not after I yield 11%+ a few times.
If I do this twice and drop my cost basis to ~$3 and then sell >$4, that's a nice 33% return.