NTRI - What happened
First, let me also be clear. I own the stocks that I present in LIVEROCKET's portfolio. I put my own money where my mouth is. I know the pain all to owell when one of my choices goes down. And for anyone following my advice, I feel a heavy burden when my suggestons don't immediately pan out.
On the one hand, this is a good time to remind everyone about the hazards of picking one stock out of the LIVEROCKET portfolio and going with it. This is a portfolio which is hedging growth in several markets. As soon as you go with just one stock out of this portfolio, you open yourself up to a lot of risk.
That still doesn't make up for buying a stinker. Or is this a stinker? I don't think so - NTRI released some very good news, only to plummet from the $48 buy price to $41.xx.
NTRI pre-announced as follows.
Sales: $70M or 12% higher than expected
Earnings: $0.16 estimated and that's $0.01 below consensus expectations
Then they provided guidance for 2006 and for this quarter
Q1 revenues: ~$115M (versus $37M last year Q1) or up 200%
Customer base growing 170%
Q1 earnings: estimated at $0.35~$0.38 (versus $0.33 consensus)
Why would the market care about one penny this quarter when NTRI went on record that it expects to exceed by up to 5 pennies next quarter? I believe that it is partly the pre-earnings run up and partly because the market was shocked that sales growth was 'falling' from 600% to 200%. As an investor, I never expected that 600% number to remain: Q4 '04 was the last quarter before NTRI began selling on QVC or when their sales jumped from $8M to $37M.
Track the sales
Q4 '04 $8M
Q1 '05 $37M
Q2 '05 $41M
Q3 '05 $67M
Q4 '05 $70M
Q1 '06 est $115M
Analysts will also have to revise 2006 earnings expectations, currently at $1.22. If NTRI hits $0.35 this quarter and holds at that level, that's a 20% upside surprise for analysts. And that assumes flat sales. If they even grow beyond today, that's more upside surprise.
Forward P/E today ($1.22) 34
Forward P/E revised ($1.40) 30
Forward P/E with 10% upside ($1.54) 27
(Can they hit their target numbers? As we roll out of holiday season and Spring comes forward, expect lots of advertising around getting in shape for bikini season.)
This is a company with sales more than tripling, earnings doubling, but they are getting a P/E of ~30???? THIS IS A SCREAMING BUY OPPORTUNITY.
Keep the faith. As we get closer to next quarter, people will start to wake up to the doubling of earnings and get excited again.