Thursday, January 10, 2008

Don't Fear a Recession


I tried to express my thoughts in a simple diagram.
The last few years have been artifically stimulated demand (the bubble demand I indicate above). Call it the housing economy: part house sales and part home loan boosted consumer spending. Home sales contributed 5.5% to the GDP in 2006. That dropped to 5.1% in Q2 of 2007.
In other words - the GDP was artificially inflated by the simple fact of more home sales at higher prices. With fewer home sales, GDP will naturally drop. So negative growth is inevitable and in and of itself not a problem. The underlying economy continues to roar away, in normal cases.
Where it becomes a problem is the second bubble I chart above. Bumping up housing today is really borrowing from tomorrow's demand. That's a bit of a systemic problem for the longer haul for the construction, financial and real estate sectors.
But a bigger problem is that the housing economy included borrowing against that asset (and other excesses). Again, that is what boosted the GDP and made it appear robust. Remove that spending and GDP drops. The only other option is for folks to buy more cars, iPods and so forth. Dump that 3 year old furniture and buy a new set.
But that isn't goingto happen. So GDP will drop.
We shouldn't worry about a slowing GDP caused by slowing housing sales - that's just math. We should worry about the drop in consumer spending. That's when recessions lead to broader economic slowdown.
I believe that massive rate cuts will spur some spending. For example, I bought a car last year and used a credit card offer by Citibank to transfer a balance and pay 0% interest for 12 months. I just got another offer, good for 15 months. I'm going to use that one next. A low interest rate enables these offers. And it frees up my cash for other things to buy.
This reduces the severity of the broader recession.
As more information comes out, focus on consumer spending habits and not on the GDP number.

1 Comments:

Blogger TakeStocK said...

Andrew, I see Dow @12500 as a buying opportunity at least for a short term. Sooner Fed officials,Saudi’s,Chinese come into picture and run up till the Fed rate cut date.

I think recession fear is little bit overdone..Infy results this week were the proof. They gave better than expected growth and even raised the guidance for 2008. It came as surprise because some of their main clients are the Banks which got hit in the Subprime..Infy being a very conservative company I guess there is no Bull shit here..

2008, India and china already projected 8 & 10% growth with recession in US or not . Also I think Energy & Infra companies will show a robust growth and spectacular results since they have a huge backlog of orders. $ won’t fall that steep as expected because BOE & BOJ hinted about the rate cut followed by central Bank of India likely to cut in a month or so…that left with the china the high interest rate there already is a concern.

I don’t agree with the theory that Dow will fall below 10,000 levels. We can not compare the 91 recession to now because in 1991& 2001, where was India & China? If Dow has to fall below 10,000 levels ,it will be an once in a life time opportunity and few new Warren Buffets will be born right out of your Blog:-)

10:19 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home